iPad 5 (2017, A9 series) Vs iPad mini 5 (2019, A12 series)

iPad 5 (2017, A9 series)
iPad 5 (2017, A9 series)
Starting at

Refurbished price:79.00

Versus €409.00 new

See options
iPad mini 5 (2019, A12 series)
iPad mini 5 (2019, A12 series)
Starting at

Refurbished price:195.00

Versus €469.00 new

See options

Ratings

The iPad 2017, also known as the 5th generation iPad, and the iPad Mini 2019, the 5th generation of the iPad Mini line, are two distinct tablet computers from Apple, released in March 2017 and March 2019, respectively. While both run on Apple's iPadOS, they cater to different user preferences primarily through their size, processing power, and display technologies. This comparison will delve into their practical differences to help users make an informed decision.

Scores

Durability

The longevity of a tablet is often determined by its release date and subsequent software support, alongside its physical durability. These two models present a clear difference in their expected software lifespan.

  • Release Timeline: The iPad 2017 was released in March 2017, making it an older device compared to the iPad Mini 2019, which launched two years later in March 2019. This age difference directly impacts their software support lifespan.
  • Software Longevity: The iPad 2017 received its last major operating system update with iPadOS 16, meaning it will no longer receive new feature updates, though it may still get security patches. In contrast, the iPad Mini 2019 currently supports iPadOS 17 and is expected to receive further major OS updates for a longer period, offering extended access to new features and security enhancements.
  • Practical Lifespan: For users prioritizing the latest software features and long-term compatibility with new applications, the iPad Mini 2019 offers a more extended practical lifespan. Both devices feature robust aluminum builds, typical of Apple products, providing a similar level of physical durability for everyday use.

Year of Release

2017

2019

Compatible with latest Update

No

Yes

OS

iPadOS

iPadOS

Maximum Operating System supported

iPadOS 16

iPadOS 18

Performance

The performance of these tablets varies significantly due to the difference in their internal processing components, impacting how smoothly they handle various tasks.

  • Processing Capabilities: The iPad 2017 is equipped with a processor that handles everyday tasks, web browsing, and casual gaming smoothly. The iPad Mini 2019, however, features a more advanced processor, enabling it to manage demanding applications, complex multitasking, and graphically intensive games with greater responsiveness and efficiency.
  • Multitasking and Responsiveness: Users will notice that the iPad Mini 2019 offers a more fluid experience when switching between multiple applications or running several processes simultaneously, thanks to its more capable internal architecture. This translates to quicker app loading times and a more seamless overall user experience.
  • Battery Behavior: Both tablets offer robust battery performance for their respective designs. The iPad 2017, with its larger battery capacity, can provide up to 10 hours of mixed usage, including web browsing and video playback. The iPad Mini 2019, despite its smaller physical size, also delivers comparable battery life for typical use, benefiting from a more power-efficient processor.

Memory (GB)

2 GB

3 GB

Processor

Apple A9

Apple A12 Bionic

Screen quality

The visual experience on these two tablets presents notable differences, primarily influenced by their display technologies and physical dimensions.

  • Display Technology and Clarity: Both devices feature Retina IPS LCD displays, offering sharp text and clear images. The iPad 2017 has a 9.7-inch display with a resolution of 2048 x 1536 pixels at 264 pixels per inch (ppi). The iPad Mini 2019, while smaller at 7.9 inches, maintains the same 2048 x 1536 pixel resolution, resulting in a higher pixel density of 326 ppi, which provides a slightly crisper visual experience.
  • Brightness and Color: The iPad Mini 2019's display is fully laminated, which reduces the gap between the glass and the display, and supports True Tone technology, which automatically adjusts the screen's color temperature to match ambient lighting. It also offers P3 wide color gamut for more vibrant and accurate colors. The iPad 2017's screen is bright but lacks these advanced features, and is not fully laminated.
  • Viewing Experience: The larger 9.7-inch screen of the iPad 2017 provides a more expansive viewing area for media consumption and general browsing. The 7.9-inch display of the iPad Mini 2019, while smaller, offers a more portable and compact viewing experience, ideal for reading or use on the go.

Resolution

2048 x 1536

2048 x 1536

True Tone

No

Yes

Pro-Motion

No

No

Screen type

Retina display

Retina display

Pixel density

264ppp

326ppp

Brightness

500 nits brightness

500 nits brightness

Sound quality

Speakers

Stereo speakers

Stereo speakers

Audiovisual

The camera systems on these two iPads offer different capabilities, particularly for front-facing interactions and overall image processing.

  • Rear Camera Performance: Both the iPad 2017 and the iPad Mini 2019 feature an 8-megapixel rear camera. This allows for decent everyday photography and document scanning. The image processing capabilities of the newer processor in the iPad Mini 2019 may result in slightly improved photo quality, especially in challenging lighting conditions.
  • Front Camera and Video Calls: A significant difference lies in the front-facing camera. The iPad 2017 has a 1.2-megapixel front camera, suitable for basic video calls. The iPad Mini 2019 features a 7-megapixel front camera, providing much clearer and more detailed images for selfies and video conferencing.
  • Audio Experience: Both devices include stereo speakers, providing a satisfactory audio experience for media consumption. They also retain a 3.5mm headphone jack, offering flexibility for wired audio accessories.

Miscellaneous

Beyond core performance and display, several practical elements differentiate these two iPad models, influencing their daily usability.

  • Connectivity Options: Both tablets support Wi-Fi for wireless internet, and cellular models are available for mobile data access. The iPad Mini 2019 benefits from Bluetooth 5.0, offering more stable and efficient connections with accessories compared to the iPad 2017's Bluetooth 4.2.
  • Port Types and Sensors: Both devices utilize the Lightning port for charging and data transfer and include a 3.5mm headphone jack. Both also feature Touch ID for secure authentication. A key differentiator is Apple Pencil support; the iPad Mini 2019 is compatible with the 1st generation Apple Pencil, enabling note-taking and drawing, which the iPad 2017 does not support.
  • Weight and Dimensions: The iPad 2017 is larger and heavier, measuring 240 x 169.5 x 7.5 mm and weighing 469g (Wi-Fi). The iPad Mini 2019 is significantly more compact and lighter at 203.2 x 134.8 x 6.1 mm and 300.5g (Wi-Fi), making it more portable and easier to handle with one hand.

Weight

469 g

300 g

Width

16.95 cm

13.48 cm

Height

24 cm

23.32 cm

Depth

0.75 cm

0.61 cm

Screen size (in)

9.7

7.9

Network

Wi-Fi

Wi-Fi

Carrier compatibility

Without SIM Port

Without SIM Port

Wi-Fi technology

Wi-Fi 6 802.11a/b/g/n/ac

Wi-Fi 6 802.11a/b/g/n/ac

Bluetooth Version

Bluetooth 4.2

Bluetooth 5.0

Face ID

No

No

Touch ID

Yes

Yes

Connector

Lightning connector

Lightning connector

User sentiment for the iPad 2017 often praises its larger screen size, which remains suitable for media consumption and general web browsing. It is frequently noted as a functional device for basic tasks, especially for those who do not require the latest features. However, common criticisms revolve around its aging processor and the cessation of major iPadOS updates, which can lead to slower performance with newer applications and a lack of access to the latest software functionalities.

The iPad Mini 2019 is widely lauded for its exceptional portability, significantly stronger performance for demanding apps, and its improved front camera, making it a preferred choice for video calls. The addition of 1st generation Apple Pencil support is also a frequently praised feature for note-takers and digital artists. Some users, however, find the smaller screen size less ideal for extensive multitasking or immersive media viewing compared to larger tablets.

Users prioritizing a larger display for casual browsing, media consumption, or basic productivity tasks may find the iPad 2017 well-suited to their needs. Conversely, users who value portability, robust performance for more intensive applications, enhanced front camera capabilities for communication, and Apple Pencil support for creative or professional work will likely lean towards the iPad Mini 2019. Both models offer a reliable tablet experience, and choosing between them depends on individual priorities regarding screen size, performance demands, and feature set. Considering a quality-assured refurbished option for either model can be an eco-friendly alternative for consumers.

See all articles

Our recent comparisons