I received the first MagSafe with cuts on the cable. I contacted the backmarket and reported this.
A replacement was sent to me again without further queries.
These things are bond to happen every now and then, but what's not common it's to see such an outstanding customer service.
I feel confident that if something goes wrong the people at backmarket will be there to respond positively on a genuine issue.
The post could be a bit faster, took 6 days each time to receive the order. It's not crazy slow but I needed the replacement ASAP as I had no power on my mac.
If you don't need your stuff within 48 hrs or so, go for it. they are good in my experience